Playing the Market: How Understanding Supply and Demand Can Get You Better Rates

Owner operators should grasp the market, negotiate, and pick right loads for better rates. When trucks exceed loads, brokers win; when loads exceed trucks, you do

DISPATCHING 101

Edward Seporaitis

12/7/20239 min read

Key Factors for Getting Good Rates as a New Owner Operator


When you first start out as an owner operator, it can be challenging to get the best rates for your services. Unlike large fleets with established contracts, independent truckers need to understand market forces and negotiate effectively to maximize their earnings. While it takes time to learn the ropes, focusing on several key areas can help you secure more competitive rates as a new entrant to the trucking industry.


In this guide, we'll explore the main factors that enable owner operators to get good rates for hauls. We'll look at understanding trucking market conditions, negotiating effectively with brokers, choosing profitable loads, managing expenses efficiently, optimizing taxes, leveraging technology, building relationships in the industry, maintaining good credit, and more. By focusing on these critical aspects of the business, you can gain the knowledge and skills needed to get the rates your services deserve - even as a new trucker. With hard work and persistence, you can progress from receiving decent rates to earning great rates.


While it involves effort to excel as an independent trucker, mastering the essentials we'll cover can help you get fair rates, thrive in the business, and avoid being taken advantage of as a new operator. If you educate yourself on the key factors within your control, you can get the rates you need to achieve your goals as an owner-operator. This guide will equip you with the insights and best practices to help you maximize your earnings potential in the exciting trucking industry. Let's get started!


Understand the Trucking Market


The trucking market operates according to basic supply and demand economics. When there are more available trucks than loads in a particular market, it becomes a buyer's market. With an abundance of truck capacity competing for limited loads, carriers end up accepting lower rates in order to secure loads.


On the other hand, when there are more loads needing to be shipped than available trucks in an area, it becomes a seller's market. Carriers can command higher rates due to the demand for their services exceeding the available supply.


Regional differences significantly impact local market conditions across the country. Certain major shipping lanes and distribution hubs may have consistent demand, while more remote regions can vary dramatically between hot and cold markets.


Seasonal produce harvests, holidays, and other events can rapidly change supply and demand variables in a given region. Understanding the seasonal and geographic nuances of your operating areas is crucial to anticipating market shifts and adjusting your bidding and operations accordingly.


Monitoring load board volumes, spot market rate indexes, and other data sources can help you read market indicators and know when to hold out for better rates or lock in contracted freight to weather weak conditions. Ultimately, familiarity with local supply and demand factors will help you make informed business decisions.


Negotiate Effectively with Brokers


Negotiating effectively with brokers is crucial for getting good rates as an owner-operator. Brokers want to pay as little as possible to truckers, while truckers want to get paid as much as they can for each load. Meeting somewhere in the middle requires effective negotiation tactics.


Some tips for negotiating higher rates with brokers include:


- Know your costs. Calculate your true operating costs per mile so you know the minimum rate you need to profit. Factor in costs like fuel, maintenance, insurance, etc.


- Have alternative load options. If you have other loads lined up, you can negotiate from a position of strength and walk away if the broker won't meet your minimum rate.


- Leverage relationships. Building strong relationships with brokers over time can help you negotiate, as they may prioritize working with truckers they know and trust.


- Be firm but friendly. Negotiate assertively for the rate you need, but avoid being overly aggressive or hostile, which can damage the relationship.


- Offer win-win solutions. Consider negotiating contract rates or volume discounts that benefit both parties. This incentivizes the broker to give you more business.


- Ask questions and clarify details. Understand as much as possible about the load details, so you can build your negotiation strategy.


- Follow up after a negotiation. Maintain communication after negotiating to build the relationship for the future.


With preparation, persistence and relationship-building, owner-operators can gradually improve at negotiating win-win rates with brokers over time. It's an essential skill for succeeding in the trucking business.


Choose the Right Loads


Choosing the right loads is crucial for maximizing your revenue as an owner operator. There are several key factors to consider when evaluating loads:


Factor in Route, Distance, Weight, and Perishability


- Route - Avoid routes with tolls, major congestion, or other hassles that can eat into your time and profits. Analyze route options to find the most efficient path.


- Distance - Longer hauls tend to be more profitable per mile than short hauls. But also factor in time spent loading/unloading and getting back into position for the next load.


- Weight - Heavier loads generally pay more, but make sure you don't exceed your truck's weight capacity. Loads with partial drops can be lucrative.


- Perishability - Loads of perishable goods often pay premium rates, but require temperature-controlled trailers and timely deliveries. Avoid these if you can't accommodate the requirements.


Use Load Boards Effectively


- Check multiple free and paid load boards to compare options. Set up alerts for your ideal loads.


- Negotiate rates up when demand is high. Be ready to book loads quickly when rates surge.


- Build relationships with brokers that consistently post good loads. Let them know you prioritize their loads.


Avoid Known Bottlenecks


- Check traffic and construction reports to avoid routes with delays that can cut into your productivity and profits.


- Avoid loads with delivery times through major metro areas during peak commute hours.


- Have contingency plans in place for breakdowns, accidents, and other delays to minimize impact.


Manage Expenses


As an owner-operator, your profitability depends greatly on how well you manage expenses. There are two main types of expenses to keep in mind:


Fixed Costs


These are costs that remain relatively stable and don't fluctuate with the number of miles you run. Fixed costs include expenses like:


- Truck payments

- Insurance

- Any monthly services or subscriptions


To optimize your fixed costs:


- Consider buying an older truck outright rather than financing a new truck

- Shop around for competitive insurance rates

- Review services to see if any can be cancelled or downgraded


Variable Costs


Variable costs are directly correlated with the number of miles driven. The biggest variable cost is fuel. Maintenance and repairs also fall into this category.


To minimize variable costs:


- Improve fuel economy through preventative maintenance, driving techniques, weight reduction, etc.

- Perform routine maintenance to avoid major repairs

- Learn basic maintenance tasks to avoid shop fees

- Use fuel discounts and plan routes to get the best fuel prices


Carefully tracking all expenses and making adjustments to reduce costs can significantly impact your bottom line. Running a lean operation takes work, but frugality pays off.


Optimize Taxes


As an owner-operator, taxes can significantly impact your bottom line. Here are some tips to optimize your tax situation:


- Understand owner operator tax deductions and write-offs - There are many expenses you can deduct as an owner-operator including fuel, maintenance, repairs, supplies, insurance, per diem, mileage, cell phone, tolls, truck payments, and more. Keep detailed records and work with an accountant to maximize your write-offs.


- Set aside enough for quarterly taxes- As an independent contractor, you need to pay estimated quarterly taxes on your earnings. Calculate what you'll likely owe for the year and set aside 25% per quarter to avoid penalties. Pay on time and keep records.


- Hire an accountant if needed - Taxes can get complicated for owner-operators. Consider hiring an accountant familiar with the trucking industry who can advise you on deductions, incorporate your business, set up bookkeeping and help prepare your quarterly and annual tax filings. Their expertise can save you money in the long run.


Optimizing your taxes through deductions, proper withholdings, and working with an accountant can help put more money in your pocket as an owner-operator. Keep good records and use a tax professional to maximize your bottom line.


Leverage Technology


Technology has become an indispensable tool for owner-operators to improve efficiency, find better loads and rates, and simplify operations and administration. Adopting the right technology solutions can significantly impact an owner-operator's bottom line.


Load Boards and Rate Indexes


Load boards like Truckstop.com and DAT Power provide a platform to search for available loads and compare rates across different regions and lanes. Rate indexes like the DAT Truckload Volume Index can help owner-operators benchmark and negotiate rates effectively. Monitoring load board rates and indexes provides crucial real-time data to find the best loads with highest rates.


Apps and ELDs


Apps integrated with electronic logging devices (ELDs) help automate hours of service and compliance. Apps like Motive help manage logs, GPS tracking, IFTA reporting, and vehicle inspections digitally. ELDs improve an owner-operator's safety record while apps reduce paperwork and administrative overhead.


Accounting and GPS Software


Software like Quickbooks helps owner-operators manage accounting, get mileage reports for IFTA taxes, import bank statements, generate invoices and manage billing. GPS and asset tracking solutions like GPS Insight provide vehicle location and performance data to optimize routes and improve fuel efficiency. The right software saves time on accounting tasks and provides data to improve operations.


By leveraging the latest technology solutions for the transportation industry, owner-operators can significantly increase productivity and profitability. The benefits range from finding better loads to streamlining compliance and reducing overhead.


Build Strategic Relationships


As an owner operator, building strong relationships in the industry can significantly impact your success and profitability. Here are some ways to cultivate strategic relationships:


Partner with good brokers and shippers


- Take the time to identify and work with brokers and shippers that are fair, transparent, and pay reliably. Avoid ones that nickel and dime you or drag their feet on payments.


- Communicate proactively with brokers and shippers to understand their needs and preferences. The more they trust you, the more loads they will offer.


- Go above and beyond on loads for brokers and shippers you want to partner with long-term. Quality work and good communication will be remembered.


Network with other owner operators


- Attend industry events and join online forums to connect with other small fleet owners and independent drivers.


- Exchange tips and information on optimizing your business - everything from maintenance advice to good brokers to work with.


- Cover each other's loads when needed. Having a network of trusted operators helps deal with the inevitable challenges in this business.


Join trade associations


- Look into membership in owner-operator trade associations like the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA).


- These groups provide valuable education, advocacy, and other resources for running a successful small trucking business.


- Trade associations help give independent drivers a collective voice when dealing with legislation and regulation.


Strategic relationships are key for an owner-operator to thrive in the trucking industry. Taking the time to build partnerships and connections will pay dividends for your business.


Maintain Good Credit


Having good credit is crucial for an owner-operator's business. Good credit can help you get approved for loans and lines of credit to finance equipment purchases and expansions. It also shows brokers and shippers that your business is financially responsible.


There are a few key ways owner-operators can build and maintain strong business credit:


- Get a business credit card - Having credit cards in your business's name, instead of your own, helps build credit under your business. Make sure to use the cards responsibly by paying balances in full each month.


- Apply for credit accounts with suppliers - Opening vendor credit accounts for expenses like fuel, maintenance, tires, etc. and paying them on time helps demonstrate you can handle business credit.


- Check business credit reports regularly - Monitoring your business credit reports from sources like Experian, Equifax, and Dun & Bradstreet enables you to spot any errors or suspicious activity.


- Don't mix business and personal finances - Keeping your personal and business financial accounts separate maintains clear records for your business credit profile.


- Pay all bills on time - Late or missing payments get reported to credit bureaus and can significantly damage your business credit standing. Set up autopay or reminders to pay bills by the due date.


Maintaining excellent business credit takes time and diligence, but it can provide major advantages for financing and operations as an owner-operator. Monitoring your credit reports, minimizing debt, and demonstrating responsible use of credit accounts will help build a strong credit profile.


Conclusion


In summary, key factors for getting good rates as a new owner operator include:


- Understanding the market dynamics and supply/demand in the areas you operate

- Negotiating effectively with brokers by knowing your costs, having alternatives, and being confident

- Choosing the right loads that align with your business model and goals

- Managing expenses to maximize profitability

- Optimizing taxes through deductions, business entity selection, and working with an accountant

- Leveraging technology like apps, ELDs, and routing software to improve efficiency

- Building relationships with quality brokers, shippers, and other carriers

- Maintaining good credit to improve loan/financing options


Starting an owner operator business takes research, planning, and focus. Joining resources and communities for new truckers can provide valuable insights from experienced operators. Helpful next steps include talking to other successful owner ops, reading educational books/blogs, and working with a small business coach or accountant. The trucking community is a great resource for collaborating and learning from fellow operators. With the right knowledge, relationships, and effort you can build a thriving transportation company.